Despite foreclosure inventories, foreclosure sales drop
Discovery Bay, CA, March 15, 2010 - ForeclosureRadar (www.foreclosureradar.com), the only website that tracks every California foreclosure and provides daily auction updates, issued its monthly California Foreclosure Report for for February 2010. After reaching the lowest level in a year last month, Notice of Defaults, the start of the foreclosure process, increased by 19.7 percent in February. The number of properties scheduled for foreclosure sale remained near record levels, yet foreclosure sales, either Back to Bank or Sold to 3rd Parties, dropped by 11.9 percent total.
"The disconnect between delinquencies, and foreclosure sales continues to widen," says Sean O'Toole, Founder and CEO of ForeclosureRadar.com. "While efforts to slow foreclosures are clearly working, it remains unclear that anything has yet addressed the core problem of excess household mortgage debt."
Foreclosure Filings
Notice of Default |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| 19.69% |
-37.74% |
Notice of Trustee Sale |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| 3.58% |
33.33% |
After four consecutive months of decline, Notice of Default filings bounced up by 19.7 percent to 31,004
filings. Filings of Notices of Trustee Sale, which sets the date and time of the foreclosure auction, increased
slightly as well, rising 3.6 percent to 28,195 filings.
| 8-Sep |
8-Oct |
8-Nov |
8-Dec |
9-Jan |
9-Feb |
9-Mar |
9-Apr |
9-May |
9-Jun |
9-Jul |
9-Aug |
9-Sep |
9-Oct |
9-Nov |
9-Dec |
10-Jan |
10-Feb |
| 16746 | 17361 | 21857 | 43974 | 40580 | 49799 | 58623 | 47337 | 42203 | 47093 | 47530 | 37063 | 38175 | 36534 | 30478 | 27200 | 25904 | 31004
|
| 19674 | 26402 | 28468 | 28449 | 24890 | 21147 | 34559 | 31556 | 43355 | 30711 | 40757 | 34224 | 33112 | 38558 | 28170 | 28475 | 27220 | 28195
|
Foreclosure Outcomes
Back to Bank (REO) |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| -14.34% |
-27.67% |
Cancellations |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| 0.88% |
98.974% |
Sold to 3rd Party |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| -2.72% |
184.83% |
Foreclosure sales are the last step in the foreclosure process and result in the property being transferred from the homeowner either back to the bank, or to a 3rd party, typically an investor. Foreclosure sales decreased 11.9 percent in February, with the portion going Back to Bank dropping by 14.3 percent and the
portion to 3rd Parties dropping by 2.7 percent. Despite our prediction that we may see a wave of Cancellations as the Administration pushed to make trial loan modification permanent, Cancellations remained flat, likely indicating that the Home Affordable Modification Program conversion drive is failing.
| 8-Sep |
8-Oct |
8-Nov |
8-Dec |
9-Jan |
9-Feb |
9-Mar |
9-Apr |
9-May |
9-Jun |
9-Jul |
9-Aug |
9-Sep |
9-Oct |
9-Nov |
9-Dec |
10-Jan |
10-Feb |
| 22112 | 13296 | 15267 | 15608 | 14533 | 16419 | 9201 | 12145 | 15864 | 19713 | 14632 | 14367 | 13155 | 16018 | 14165 | 12471 | 13943 | 11943
|
| 6368 | 11281 | 8302 | 6445 | 6717 | 6904 | 6352 | 6707 | 7162 | 8674 | 10818 | 10004 | 8660 | 8757 | 10487 | 13287 | 13859 | 13737
|
| 1076 | 825 | 952 | 833 | 893 | 1266 | 1094 | 1653 | 2305 | 2694 | 2691 | 3285 | 3411 | 3960 | 3683 | 2629 | 3707 | 3606
|
Foreclosure Inventories
Preforeclosure |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| -8.01% |
-11.99% |
Scheduled for Sale |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| -0.49% |
126.34% |
Bank Owned (REO) |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| 1.15% |
-32.43% |
Despite the increase in Notice of Default filings in February, our estimated number of properties in Preforeclosure dropped 8.0 percent due to the relatively high number of Notice of Trustee Sale filings. Properties exiting the foreclosure process nearly matched the number of new Notice of Trustee Sale filings,
leaving the number of properties Scheduled for Sale in February flat compared to January. Year-over-year, the increase in properties Scheduled for Sale is a dramatic 126.3 percent, as more and more homeowners have found themselves on the brink of foreclosure. Banks continue to resell their Bank Owned (REO) property in a timely manner, with their inventories also flat from January to February.
| 8-Sep |
8-Oct |
8-Nov |
8-Dec |
9-Jan |
9-Feb |
9-Mar |
9-Apr |
9-May |
9-Jun |
9-Jul |
9-Aug |
9-Sep |
9-Oct |
9-Nov |
9-Dec |
10-Jan |
10-Feb |
| 122266 | 114067 | 96534 | 112078 | 130550 | 159215 | 179412 | 185603 | 174243 | 186060 | 175283 | 171841 | 169860 | 154905 | 157288 | 146941 | 152322 | 140126
|
| 59226 | 59695 | 64237 | 67841 | 69374 | 64177 | 82390 | 92002 | 111824 | 113141 | 124874 | 131300 | 140382 | 149456 | 151573 | 147570 | 145977 | 145260
|
| 156804 | 148814 | 147090 | 141176 | 137331 | 135488 | 122901 | 112792 | 107762 | 106139 | 100206 | 98829 | 95479 | 93926 | 93595 | 89119 | 90510 | 91550
|
Foreclosure Discounting
The courthouse steps remain highly competitive with discounts to market value dropping from 17.5 percent in January to 15.2 percent in February. Despite fewer foreclosure sales overall in February, as well as smaller discounts due to competitive bidding, 3rd party investors purchased more foreclosures, at 23.2 percent,
than at any other time since we began tracking trustee sales in September 2006.
Foreclosure Timeframes
Time to Foreclosure |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| -2.24% |
13.17% |
Time to Resell - Bank |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| 0.00% |
0.45% |
Time to Resell - 3rd |
| Prior Month |
Prior Year |
| 0.67% |
-19.45% |
While the Time to Foreclose appears to have leveled off, the Time to Resell has increased in recent months.
It is not unusual for home sales to slow in the winter months, which would naturally impact Time to Resell.
This will be an important metric to track as we move into the Spring selling season as further increases
could indicate housing market weakness.
| 8-Sep |
8-Oct |
8-Nov |
8-Dec |
9-Jan |
9-Feb |
9-Mar |
9-Apr |
9-May |
9-Jun |
9-Jul |
9-Aug |
9-Sep |
9-Oct |
9-Nov |
9-Dec |
10-Jan |
10-Feb |
| 150 | 169 | 163 | 165 | 192 | 198 | 176 | 171 | 180 | 173 | 187 | 185 | 191 | 195 | 198 | 222 | 229 | 224
|
| 190 | 192 | 195 | 206 | 218 | 223 | 231 | 234 | 240 | 244 | 238 | 228 | 220 | 219 | 220 | 224 | 224 | 224
|
| 192 | 171 | 178 | 187 | 193 | 186 | 214 | 196 | 183 | 168 | 146 | 147 | 141 | 131 | 133 | 141 | 149 | 150 |
Foreclosure Activity By County
| |
Notice of Default |
Notice of Trustee Sale |
Back to Bank (REO) |
Sold to 3rd Party |
Comments
I've been peering through the numbers you list for foreclosure activity by county, and there seems to be some inconsistencies. For example, in the March 2010 report, February 2009 NODs in San Mateo County are listed at 406. In contrast, the March 2009 report indicates that Feb 2009 NODs in San Mateo County were 222. Similarly, the numbers for Trustee sales for the same date are inconsistent between reports. Did you change the definitions of each category in between these pollings? Have you changed sources? The inconsistencies make me wonder how useful the existing numbers are, or whether they will simply be mysteriously revised away later....
http://www.foreclosureradar.com/foreclosure-report/average-negative-equi...
Thanks in advance for the clarification!
Post new comment